Home values, rents and more in ZIP code 11965 (Shelter Island, NY)
September 2026 figures from Zillow and the U.S. Census Bureau · updated 2026-11-07
Open 11965 in ProMap- Under $1.1M
- $1.1M–$1.2M
- $1.2M–$1.9M
- $1.9M–$2.3M
- $2.3M+
- No data
How 11965 compares
The typical home in ZIP code 11965 (Shelter Island, NY) is worth about $2,086,000, according to the Zillow Home Value Index for September 2026. Home values in 11965 are 2.9 times the typical value in the New York metro area ($731,000) and 5.7 times the U.S. typical value ($366,000).
Over the past year, home values in 11965 rose 7.5%, compared with +4.9% in the New York metro area and +1.2% nationally.
About 404 people live in 11965 (American Community Survey 2020–24).
11965 has the 27th-highest typical home value of the 815 ZIP codes in the New York metro area and the 20th-highest of 1,561 in New York with Zillow figures.
Part of: Shelter Island, NY · Suffolk County, NY · New York metro area · New York
More for 11965 in ProMap Plus
These measures are on the map for subscribers. Open ProMap to see them for 11965 and every other place.
- 5- and 10-year price changes
- Days on market and months of supply
- Price cuts and sale-to-list ratio
- Price-to-income and monthly cost to buy
- Zillow 12-month price forecast
- Crime rates
- School test scores
- Homeowners insurance premiums
- Commute time to downtown
- Flood, wildfire and natural hazard risk
- Property-tax rate
- 2024 presidential vote
- Age, education and household make-up
- Amenities and transit nearby
Nearby ZIP codes
Sources
Home values: Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI), all homes, middle tier, smoothed and seasonally adjusted, September 2026. Rents: Zillow Observed Rent Index (ZORI), seasonally adjusted. Population: Census population estimates (July 2025) for states, metros and counties; ACS 2020–24 for cities and ZIP codes. Income: U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 2020–24 5-year estimates. Boundaries: U.S. Census Bureau cartographic boundary files. Compiled by Home Economics.
"Typical" is Zillow's middle-tier value (homes between the 35th and 65th percentiles), not a median sale price. Changes are over the 12 months to September 2026.