Home EconomicsProMap

Best ZIP codes for schools in the Buffalo area with home values under $300,000

School test scores (grade levels vs. U.S.), 2009–19 tests (pre-pandemic), the latest comparable scores for most of the area · Stanford Education Data Archive (SEDA 2025.2) · updated 2026-11-15

18 of the 75 ZIP codes in the Buffalo area with a school figure have a typical home value under $300,000 and test scores above the U.S. average.

ZIP code 14219 (Buffalo, NY) has the highest score among them, +1.10 grade levels against the U.S. average, with a typical home value of $260,000.

The tenth, ZIP code 14012 (Barker, NY), scores +0.17; the median of all 75 ZIP codes in the area is +0.17.

See school test scores (grade levels vs. U.S.) for the Buffalo area on ProMap

Best ZIP codes for schools in the Buffalo area with home values under $300,000: the 18

ZIP codes with at least 1,000 residents, a school score above the U.S. average, a typical home value under $300,000, and a published figure are ranked (18 of them in the Buffalo area). $300,000 is the typical home value of the median ZIP code in the Buffalo area ($283,000), rounded up. * Town-level FBI figure: one figure for the whole town or county area, not neighborhood detail. Crime: violent crimes (homicide, robbery, aggravated assault) reported to police a year per 1,000 people who live or work there, 2023–25. School test scores: grades 3 to 8 math and reading in grade levels above (+) or below (−) the U.S. average; ZIP code figures weight each school district by where residents live.
RankZIP codeSchool test scores (grade levels vs. U.S.)Typical home valueViolent crimes a year per 1,000 residents and workers
114219Buffalo, NY+1.10$260,0000.4*
214224Buffalo, NY+0.80$297,0000.7*
314111North Collins, NY+0.78$257,0000.2*
414131Ransomville, NY+0.59$300,0000.2*
514043Depew, NY+0.56$271,0000.5*
614150Tonawanda, NY+0.48$258,0000.8*
714172Wilson, NY+0.43$277,0000.2*
814120North Tonawanda, NY+0.42$285,0001.2*
914141Springville, NY+0.21$262,0000.2*
1014012Barker, NY+0.17$242,000–
1114028Burt, NY+0.17$283,0000.2*
1214030Chaffee, NY+0.17$256,0000.2*
1314091Lawtons, NY+0.17$283,0000.2*
1414108Newfane, NY+0.17$251,0000.2*
1514008Appleton, NY+0.16$262,0000.2*
1614217Buffalo, NY+0.10$257,0001.1*
1714223Buffalo, NY+0.10$267,0000.8*
1814006Angola, NY+0.02$230,0000.4*
ZIP codes in the Buffalo area, shaded by school test scores (grade levels vs. U.S.)10987654321
  • Under +0.20
  • +0.20 to +0.40
  • +0.40 to +0.60
  • +0.60 or more
  • Not ranked
ZIP codes in the Buffalo area, shaded by school test scores (grade levels vs. U.S.). Numbers mark the first 10 places in the table; dashed lines are county borders. Stanford Education Data Archive (SEDA 2025.2).

More rankings for the Buffalo area

Best ZIP codes for schools under $300,000 in other metro areas

Source and method

School test scores (grade levels vs. U.S.): Stanford Education Data Archive (SEDA 2025.2); figures for 2009–19 tests (pre-pandemic), the latest comparable scores for most of the area. ZIP codes with at least 1,000 residents, a school score above the U.S. average, a typical home value under $300,000, and a published figure are ranked (18 of them in the Buffalo area). $300,000 is the typical home value of the median ZIP code in the Buffalo area ($283,000), rounded up. * Town-level FBI figure: one figure for the whole town or county area, not neighborhood detail. Crime: violent crimes (homicide, robbery, aggravated assault) reported to police a year per 1,000 people who live or work there, 2023–25. School test scores: grades 3 to 8 math and reading in grade levels above (+) or below (−) the U.S. average; ZIP code figures weight each school district by where residents live. The metro area is the Buffalo-Cheektowaga, NY metropolitan statistical area. Place names for ZIP codes are the neighborhood or city the ZIP code mostly covers. Compiled by Home Economics.

Zillow's "typical" home value and rent are index values for the middle of the market (the Zillow Home Value Index and Observed Rent Index), not median sale prices or asking rents. One-year changes are over the 12 months to September 2026. Income and population come from the Census Bureau's American Community Survey and carry sampling error, most of all in small places.

Open the Buffalo area on the map